Scinovex
article Open AccessTop 1% cited

THE RATE OF BINARY BLACK HOLE MERGERS INFERRED FROM ADVANCED LIGO OBSERVATIONS SURROUNDING GW150914

The Astrophysical Journal Letters · 2016 · Vol. 833(1) · pp. L1–L1
B. P. AbbottR. AbbottT. D. AbbottM. R. AbernathyF. AcerneseK. AckleyC. AdamsT. AdamsP. AddessoR. X. AdhikariV. B. AdyaC. AffeldtM. AgathosK. AgatsumaN. AggarwalO. D. AguiarL. AielloA. AinP. AjithB. AllenA. AlloccaP. A. AltinS. B. AndersonW. G. AndersonK. AraiM. C. ArayaC. C. ArceneauxJ. S. AreedaN. ArnaudK. G. ArunS. AscenziG. AshtonM. AstS. M. AstonP. AstoneP. AufmuthC. AulbertS. BabakP. BaconM. K. M. BaderP. T. BakerF. BaldacciniG. BallardinS. W. BallmerJ. C. BarayogaS. E. BarclayB. C. BarishD. BarkerF. BaroneB. BarrL. BarsottiM. BarsugliaD. BartaJ. BartlettI. BartosR. BassiriA. BastiJ. C. BatchC. BauneV. BavigaddaM. BazzanB. BehnkeM. BejgerA. S. BellC. BellB. K. BergerJ. BergmanG. BergmannC. P. L. BerryD. BersanettiA. BertoliniJ. BetzwieserS. BhagwatR. BhandareI. A. BilenkoG. BillingsleyJ. BirchR. BirneyS. BiscansA. BishtM. BitossiC. BiwerM. A. BizouardJ. K. BlackburnC. D. BlairD. G. BlairR. M. BlairS. BloemenO. BockT. P. BodiyaM. BoërG. BogaertC. BoganA. BohéP. BojtosC. BondF. BonduR. BonnandB. A. BoomR. BorkV. BoschiS. BoseY. BouffanaisA. BozziC. BradaschiaP. R. BradyV. B. BraginskyM. BranchesiJ. E. BrauT. BriantA. BrilletM. BrinkmannV. BrissonP. BrockillA. F. BrooksD. BrownD. BrownN. M. BrownC. C. BuchananA. BuikemaT. BulikH. J. BultenA. BuonannoD. BuskulicC. BuyR. L. ByerL. CadonatiG. CagnoliC. CahillaneJ. Calderón BustilloT. A. CallisterE. CalloniJ. B. CampK. C. CannonJ. CaoC. D. CapanoE. CapocasaF. CarbognaniS. CarideJ. Casanueva DiazC. CasentiniS. CaudillM. CavagliàF. CavalierR. CavalieriG. CellaC. CepedaL. Cerboni BaiardiG. CerretaniE. CesariniR. ChakrabortyT. ChalermsongsakS. J. ChamberlinM. ChanS. ChaoP. CharltonE. Chassande‐MottinYu‐Hung ChenYu‐Hung ChenC. ChengA. ChincariniA. ChiummoH. S. ChoM. ChoJ. H. ChowN. ChristensenQ. ChuS. ChuaS. ChungG. CianiF. ClaraJ. A. ClarkF. ClevaE. CocciaP.‐F. CohadonA. CollaChristophe ColletteL. CominskyM. ConstancioA. ConteL. ContiD. CookT. R. CorbittNeil J. CornishA. CorsiS. CorteseC. A. CostaM. W. CoughlinS. B. CoughlinJ.-P. CoulonS. T. CountrymanP. CouvaresE. E. CowanD. M. CowardM. J. CowartD. C. CoyneR. CoyneK. CraigJ. D. E. CreightonJ. CripeS. G. CrowderA. CummingL. CunninghamE. CuocoT. Dal CantonS. L. DanilishinS. D’AntonioK. DanzmannN. S. DarmanV. DattiloI. DaveH. DavelozaM. DavierG. S. DaviesE. J. DawR. DayD. DeBraD. DeBraG. DebreczeniJ. DegallaixM. De LaurentisS. DelégliseW. Del PozzoT. DenkerT. DentH. DereliV. DergachevR. De RosaR. T. DeRosaR. DeSalvoS. DhurandharM. C. DíazL. Di FioreM. Di GiovanniA. Di LietoS. Di PaceI. Di PalmaA. Di VirgilioG. DojcinoskiV. DoliqueF. DonovanK. L. DooleyS. DoravariR. DouglasT. P. DownesM. DragoR. W. P. DreverJennifer C DriggersZhihui DuM. DucrotS. E. DwyerT. B. EdoM. C. EdwardsA. EfflerH.-B. EggensteinP. EhrensJ. EichholzS. S. EikenberryW. EngelsR. C. EssickT. EtzelM. EvansT. M. EvansR. EverettM. FactourovichV. FafoneH. FairS. FairhurstX. FanQ. FangS. FarinonB. FarrWill M. FarrM. FavataM. FaysH. FehrmannM. M. FejerI. FerranteE. C. FerreiraF. FerriniF. FidecaroI. FioriD. FiorucciR. P. FisherR. FlaminioM. FletcherS. M. FleischerJ.-D. FournierSebastián FrancoS. FrascaF. FrasconiZ. FreiA. FreiseR. FreyR. FreyT. T. FrickeP. FritschelV. V. FrolovP. FuldaM. FyffeH. A. GabbardJ. R. GairL. GammaitoniS. G. GaonkarF. GarufiAlberto GattoG. GaurN. GehrelsG. GemmeB. GendreE. GeninA. GennaiJ. GeorgeL. GergelyV. GermainArchisman GhoshS. GhoshJ. A. GiaimeK. D. GiardinaA. GiazottoK. GillA. GlaefkeE. GoetzE. GoetzL. GondánG. GonzálezJ. M. Gonzalez CastroA. GopakumarNeil GordonM. L. GorodetskyS. E. GossanM. GosselinR. GouatyC. GraefP. B. GraffM. GranataA. GrantS. GrasC. GrayG. GrecoA. C. GreenP. GrootH. GroteS. GrünewaldG. M. GuidiX. GuoA. GuptaManoj GuptaK. E. GushwaE. K. GustafsonR. GustafsonJ. J. HackerE. D. HallE. D. HallG. HammondM. HaneyM. M. HankeJ. HanksC. HannaM. D. HannamJ. HansonT. HardwickJ. HarmsI. W. HarryI. W. HarryM. J. HartM. T. HartmanC.‐J. HasterK. HaughianA. HeidmannM. C. HeintzeH. HeitmannP. HelloH. HeitmannM. HendryI. S. HengJ. HennigA. W. HeptonstallM. HeursS. HildD. HoakK. A. HodgeD. HofmanS. E. HollittK. HoltD. E. HolzP. HopkinsDavid J. HoskenJ. HoughE. A. HoustonE. J. HowellYi-Ming HuS. HuangE. A. HuertaD. HuetB. HugheyS. HusaS. H. HuttnerT. Huynh–DinhA. IdrisyN. IndikD. R. IngramR. IntaH. N. IsaJ.-M. IsacM. IsiG. IslasT. IsogaiB. R. IyerK. IzumiT. JacqminH. JangK. JaniP. JaranowskiS. JawaharF. Jiménez‐FortezaW. W. JohnsonD. I. JonesR. W. L. JonesR. J. G. JonkerL. JuK. HarisC. V. KalaghatgiV. KalogeraS. KandhasamyG. KangJ. B. KannerS. KarkiM. KasprzackE. KatsavounidisW. KatzmanS. KauferT. KaurK. KawabeF. KawazoeF. KéfélianM. S. KehlD. KeitelD. B. KelleyW. KellsR. KennedyJ. S. KeyA. KhalaidovskiF. Y. KhaliliI. KhanS. KhanZ. KhanЕ. А. ХазановN. KijbunchooC. KimJinwoo KimK. KimNamgyu KimNamjun KimY.‐M. KimE. J. KingP. J. KingD. L. KinzelJ. S. KisselL. KleybolteS. KlimenkoS. M. KoehlenbeckK. KokeyamaS. KoleyV. KondrashovA. KontosM. KorobkoW. Z. KorthI. KowalskaD. B. KozakV. KringelB. KrishnanA. KrólakC. KruegerG. KuehnP. KumarL. KuoA. KutyniaB. D. LackeyM. LandryJ. LangeB. LantzP. D. LaskyA. LazzariniC. LazzaroP. LeaciS. LeaveyE. O. LebigotChang‐Hwan LeeH. K. LeeHyung Mok LeeK. LeeA. LenonM. LeonardiJ. R. LeongN. LeroyN. LetendreY. LevinB. M. LevineT. G. F. LiA. LibsonT. B. LittenbergN. A. LockerbieJ. LogueA. L. LombardiJ. E. LordM. LorenziniV. LorietteM. LormandG. LosurdoJ. D. LoughH. LückA. P. LundgrenJ. LuoRyan S. LynchY. MaT. MacDonaldB. MachenschalkM. MacInnisD. M. MacleodF. Magaña‐SandovalR. M. MageeM. MageswaranE. MajoranaI. MaksimovicV. MalvezziN. ManIlya MandelV. MandicV. ManganoG. L. MansellV. ManganoM. MantovaniF. MarchesoniF. MarionSzabolcs MárkaZ. MárkaA. S. MarkosyanE. MarosF. MartelliLionel MartelliniI. W. MartinR. M. MartinД. В. МартыновJ. N. MarxK. MasonA. MasserotT. J. MassingerM. Masso‐ReidF. MatichardL. MatoneN. MavalvalaN. MazumderG. MazzoloR. McCarthyD. E. McClellandS. McCormickS. C. McGuireG. McIntyreJ. McIverD. J. McManusS. T. McWilliamsD. MeacherG. D. MeadorsJ. MeidamA. MelatosG. MendellD. Mendoza-GandaraR. A. MercerE. L. MerilhM. MerzouguiS. MeshkovC. MessengerC. MessickP. M. MeyersF. MezzaniH. MiaoC. MichelH. MiddletonЕ. Е. МихайловL. MilanoJ. MillerM. MillhouseY. MinenkovJ. MingS. MirshekariC. MishraS. MitraV. P. MitrofanovG. MitselmakherR. MittlemanA. MoggiM. MohanS. R. P. MohapatraM. MontaniB. C. MooreC. J. MooreD. MoraruG. MorenoS. R. MorrissK. MossaviB. MoursC. M. Mow‐LowryC. MuellerG. MuellerA. W. MuirArunava MukherjeeD. MukherjeeSuvodip MukherjeeN. MukundA. MullaveyJ. MünchD. MurphyP. G. MurrayA. MytidisI. NardecchiaL. NaticchioniR. K. NayakV. NeculaK. NedkovaG. NelemansM. NériA. NeunzertG. NewtonT. NguyenA. B. NielsenS. NissankeA. NitzF. NoceraD. NoltingM. E. N. NormandinL. K. NuttallJ. OberlingE. OchsnerJ. O’DellE. OelkerG. H. OginJ. J. OhS. H. OhF. OhmeM. OliverP. OppermannRichard J. OramB. O’ReillyR. O’ShaughnessyD. J. OttawayR. S. OttensH. OvermierB. J. OwenA. PaiS. A. PaiJ. R. PalamosO. PalashovC. PalombaA. Pal‐SinghH. PanC. PankowF. PannaraleB. C. PantF. PaolettiA. PaoliM. A. PapaH. R. ParisW. ParkerD. PascucciA. PasqualettiR. PassaquietiD. PassuelloB. PatricelliZ. PatrickB. L. PearlstoneM. PedrazaR. PedurandL. PekowskyA. PeleZ. PereiraA. PerrecaM. PhelpsO. J. PiccinniM. PichotF. PiergiovanniV. PierroG. PillantL. PinardI. M. PintoM. PitkinR. PoggianiP. PopolizioE. K. PorterA. PostJ. PowellJ. PrasadV. PredoiS. S. PremachandraT. PrestegardLarry R. PriceM. PrijateljM. PrincipeS. PriviteraG. A. ProdiL. ProkhorovO. PunckenM. PunturoP. PuppoM. PürrerH. QiJ. QinV. QuetschkeE. A. QuinteroR. Quitzow-JamesF. J. RaabD. S. RabelingH. RadkinsP. RaffaiS. RajaM. RakhmanovP. RapagnaniV. RaymondM. RazzanoV. ReJ. ReadC. M. ReedT. RegimbauL. ReiS. ReidD. H. ReitzeH. RewS. D. ReyesF. RicciK. RilesN. A. RobertsonR. RobieF. RobinetA. RocchiL. RollandJ. G. RollinsV. J. RomaR. RomanoG. RomanovJ. H. RomieD. RosińskaS. RowanA. RüdigerP. RuggiK. RyanS. SachdevT. SadeckiL. SadeghianL. SalconiM. SaleemF. SalemiA. SamajdarL. SammutL. M. SampsonE. J. SanchezV. SandbergB. SandeenJ. R. SandersB. SassolasB. S. SathyaprakashP. R. SaulsonO. SauterR. L. SavageA. SawadskyP. SchaleR. SchillingP. SchmidtP. SchmidtR. SchnabelR. M. S. SchofieldA. SchönbeckE. SchreiberD. SchuetteB. F. SchutzJ. ScottS. M. ScottD. SellersA. S. SenguptaD. SentenacV. SequinoA. SergeevG. SernaY. SetyawatiA. SêvignyD. A. ShaddockS. ShahM. S. ShahriarM. ShaltevZ. ShaoB. ShapiroP. ShawhanA. SheperdD. H. ShoemakerD. M. ShoemakerK. SiellezX. SiemensD. SiggA. D. SilvaD. SimakovA. SingerL. P. SingerA. SinghR. SinghA. SinghalA. M. SintesB. J. J. SlagmolenJ. R. SmithN. D. SmithR. J. E. SmithE. J. SonB. SorazuF. SorrentinoT. SouradeepA. K. SrivastavaA. StaleyM. SteinkeJ. SteinlechnerS. SteinlechnerD. SteinmeyerB. C. StephensS. P. StevensonR. StoneK. A. StrainN. StranieroG. StrattaN. A. StraussS. StriginR. SturaniA. L. StuverT. Z. SummerscalesL. SunP. J. SuttonB. L. SwinkelsM. J. SzczepańczykM. TaccaD. TalukderD. B. TannerM. TápaiS. P. TarabrinA. TaracchiniR. TaylorT. TheegM. P. ThirugnanasambandamE. G. ThomasM. ThomasP. ThomasK. A. ThorneK. S. ThorneE. ThraneShubhanshu TiwariV. TiwariK. V. TokmakovC. TomlinsonM. TonelliC. TorresM. NeryD. TöyräF. TravassoG. TraylorD. TrifiròM. C. TringaliL. TrozzoM. TseM. TurconiD. TuyenbayevD. UgoliniB. KrishnanA. L. UrbanS. A. UsmanH. VahlbruchG. VajenteG. ValdesM. VallisneriJ. F. J. van den BrandM. van BeuzekomJ. F. J. van den BrandC. Van Den BroeckD. C. Vander‐HydeL. van der SchaafJ. V. van HeijningenD. C. Vander‐HydeM. VardaroS. VassM. VasúthR. VaulinA. VecchioG. VedovatoJ. VeitchP. J. VeitchK. VenkateswaraD. VerkindtF. VetranoA. ViceréS. VinciguerraD. J. VineJ.-Y. VinetS. VitaleT. VoH. VoccaC. VorvickD. V. VossW. D. VousdenS. P. VyatchaninA. R. WadeL. E. WadeM. WadeM. WalkerL. WallaceS. WalshG. WangHan WangM. WangX. WangY. WangR. L. WardJ. WarnerM. WąsB. WeaverL.‐W. WeiM. WeinertA. J. WeinsteinR. WeissT. WelbornL. WenP. WeßelsT. WestphalK. WetteJ. T. WhelanD. J. WhiteB. F. WhitingR. D. WilliamsA. R. WilliamsonJ. L. WillisB. WillkeM. H. WimmerW. WinklerC. C. WipfH. WittelG. WoanJ. WordenJ. L. WrightGuanglei WuJ. YablonW. YamH. YamamotoC. C. YanceyM. J. YapHang YuM. YvertA. ZadrożnyL. ZangrandoM. ZanolinJ.-P. ZendriM. ZevinF. ZhangT ZhangM. ZhangY. ZhangC. ZhaoM. ZhouZ. ZhouX. J. ZhuM. E. ZuckerS. E. ZurawJ. Zweizig

Abstract

ABSTRACT A transient gravitational-wave signal, GW150914, was identified in the twin Advanced LIGO detectors on 2015 September 2015 at 09:50:45 UTC. To assess the implications of this discovery, the detectors remained in operation with unchanged configurations over a period of 39 days around the time of the signal. At the detection statistic threshold corresponding to that observed for GW150914, our search of the 16 days of simultaneous two-detector observational data is estimated to have a false-alarm rate (FAR) of , yielding a p -value for GW150914 of . Parameter estimation follow-up on this trigger identifies its source as a binary black hole (BBH) merger with component masses at redshift (median and 90% credible range). Here, we report on the constraints these observations place on the rate of BBH coalescences. Considering only GW150914, assuming that all BBHs in the universe have the same masses and spins as this event, imposing a search FAR threshold of 1 per 100 years, and assuming that the BBH merger rate is constant in the comoving frame, we infer a 90% credible range of merger rates between (comoving frame). Incorporating all search triggers that pass a much lower threshold while accounting for the uncertainty in the astrophysical origin of each trigger, we estimate a higher rate, ranging from depending on assumptions about the BBH mass distribution. All together, our various rate estimates fall in the conservative range .

Pulsars and Gravitational Waves ResearchGamma-ray bursts and supernovaeAstrophysical Phenomena and ObservationsLIGOPhysicsGravitational waveBinary black holeAstrophysicsRedshiftBinary numberRange (aeronautics)AstronomyGalaxy

Funding

  • National Science Foundation
  • Institut des Origines de Lyon
  • Leverhulme Trust
  • Scottish Funding Council
  • Scottish Universities Physics Alliance
  • European Commission
  • National Research Foundation
  • Council of Scientific and Industrial Research, India
  • Russian Foundation for Basic Research
  • Industry Canada
  • Nederlandse Organisatie voor Wetenschappelijk Onderzoek
  • Ministerio de Economía y Competitividad
  • Hungarian Scientific Research Fund
  • National Research Foundation of Korea
  • Ministry of Education, India
  • Centre National de la Recherche Scientifique
  • Ministero dello Sviluppo Economico
  • Istituto Nazionale di Fisica Nucleare
  • Govern de les Illes Balears
  • Science and Technology Facilities Council
  • Science and Engineering Research Board
  • Division of Human Resource Development
Citations
375
FWCI
53.51
field-weighted impact
References
58
Percentile
100%
vs. same field & year
Citations per year
Cited by
Steepest growth of the power spectrum and primordial black holes
Journal of Cosmology and Astroparticle Physics · 2019 · 344 citations
Merger rate of primordial black-hole binaries
Physical review. D/Physical review. D. · 2017 · 434 citations
Cosmological backgrounds of gravitational waves
Classical and Quantum Gravity · 2018 · 841 citations
Black holes, gravitational waves and fundamental physics: a roadmap
Classical and Quantum Gravity · 2019 · 718 citations
References
The Luminosity Function and Stellar Evolution.
The Astrophysical Journal · 1955 · 8,243 citations
Parameter estimation for compact binaries with ground-based gravitational-wave observations using the LALInference software library
Physical review. D. Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology/Physical review. D, Particles, fields, gravitation, and cosmology · 2015 · 922 citations
Observation of Gravitational Waves from a Binary Black Hole Merger
Physical Review Letters · 2016 · 13,779 citations
ASTROPHYSICAL IMPLICATIONS OF THE BINARY BLACK HOLE MERGER GW150914
The Astrophysical Journal Letters · 2016 · 819 citations
GW150914: First results from the search for binary black hole coalescence with Advanced LIGO
Physical review. D/Physical review. D. · 2016 · 479 citations
The PyCBC search for gravitational waves from compact binary coalescence
Classical and Quantum Gravity · 2016 · 636 citations
Citation Network

How this paper connects to the literature. Drag to explore, click any node to open that paper.